With original classics like "Only You" and "The Great Pretender," The Platters became one of the preeminent vocal groups throughout the second half of the '50s.
The group formed in 1953 when a recently discharged young Army veteran named Herb Reed recruited Cornell Gunther, Joe Jefferson, and Alex Hodge to form a vocal quartet that would eventually be called The Platters. These four men were in fact, the “original” Platters.
The Los Angeles based group made a few records for the Federal label, a subsidiary of Cincinnati's King Records. In 1954, after a failed attempt to record "Only You" (and You Alone) with Federal Records, Jefferson, Gunther and Hodge left the group. They were immediately replaced by Tony Williams, David Lynch, and Paul Robi.
That same year, Zola Taylor joined becoming the first female vocalist to break through the gender divide as part of an all-male vocal group.
This second lineup of the newly formed quintet is often mistakenly referred to as the “original Platters,” although this is the group that was actually responsible for all of The Platters hit records going forward.
What changed The Platters fortunes boils down to one man: their mentor, manager, producer, songwriter, and vocal coach, Buck Ram.
By 1954, Ram was already running a talent agency in Los Angeles, writing and arranging for publisher Mills Music, and working with his protégés, the Penguins. Who can forget their classic ultra-romantic ballad, Earth Angel. The Platters seemed like a good addition to his stable.
Under his guidance Ram took a standard doo wop vocal group and turned them into stars -- one of the most enduring and lucrative groups of all time. After adjusting the lineup he settled on lead Tony Williams, second tenor David Lynch, baritone Paul Robi, and bass Herb Reed, finally adding contralto Taylor in 1955 to complete their perfect harmonic combination. Ram believed this group would have more elegance and sophistication than the average R&B act. He was right...
Buck Ram managed to sign The Platters to a major deal with Mercury Records and it was then the trendsetting group re-recorded Only You (and You Alone) on April 26, 1955, launching them onto the national stage. Zola Taylor turned seventeen one month prior to the release of "Only You." The Platters would churn out hit after hit during the 1950s, bridging the gap between more traditional vocal-group styles and the popular R&B grooves of the early '50s.
Watch this video of the original clip from the 1956 movie "Rock Around The Clock" and then continue below to read how the song was reportedly released in error.
The Platters initial release of "Only You" was released to the public in error. A popular DJ of the time named Alan Freed accidentally played the single on air during a "prime time" that was traditionally reserved for only white artists.
The romantic ballad, based on the then groundbreaking Tin Pan Alley sound,
became an instant hit with the public and would eventually reach number
five on the pop charts, pioneering the "new sound" of rock-n-roll as we
know it today.
The phrase tin pan referred to an area in New York that housed many songwriters and the sound of pianos furiously pounded by the so-called song pluggers, who demonstrated tunes to publishers.
Tin Pan Alley comprised the commercial music of songwriters of ballads, dance music, and vaudeville, and its name eventually became synonymous with American popular music in general.
When R&B and doo wop began to crossover into the pop charts, The Platters were perfectly positioned to be the smooth, classy alternative to the street-corner sounds of the early doo wop groups.
The Platters embraced the opportunity and became a finely honed quintet of expert balladeers whose vocal harmonies were as delightful as their material was refined. That carefully crafted polish led to pop crossover status on an epic scale, and throughout the second half of the '50s, racked up a number of huge crossover hits, none better than their second Top Ten hit, "The Great Pretender." The song describes a man who deals with his heartbreak by denying it - he's mastered the art of smiling through the pain.
The Platters had two things going for them that their competitors couldn't claim: the stratospheric lead tenor of Tony Williams and the writing and managerial skills of Buck Ram.
Instead of sticking with the all-male lineup they'd started out with, the group brought in cute-as-a-button teenager Zola Taylor, further setting them apart from the great majority of their contemporaries.
"The Great Pretender" exceeded the success of their debut and became the Platters' first national #1 hit, topping the charts for 11 weeks, and were also the first group in the newly defined "Rock-n-Roll" Era to have a Top Ten album in America.
When pressed by the record label for a follow up to the success of "Only You (And You Alone)," Ram said that he wrote the song in about 20 minutes in the bathroom of the Flamingo Hotel.
The group was inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 1990 and the Vocal Group Hall of Fame in its inaugural year of 1998. "Only You" (and You Alone) and "The Great Pretender" were named songs of the century and entered in the Grammy® Hall of Fame in 1999 and 2002 respectively.
The "Platters" were the only act to have three songs included on the American Graffiti soundtrack that kicked-off an oldies revival in the early to mid 1970s: "Only You (and You Alone)," "The Great Pretender," and "Smoke Gets in Your Eyes."
One year before his death on June 4, 2012, Reed felt the thrill of a long overdue victory after a federal judge ruled he had superior rights above all others to the group’s legendary name.
This ruling, in
principle, was subsequently validated by three other federal judges as
well as two, three-judge panels in the 2nd and 9th US Circuit Courts of
Litigation involving The Platters trademark has been ongoing for more than half a century, due to the proliferation of fake “Platters” groups and individuals falsely claiming to be “Platters.”
and his company, Herb Reed Enterprises, LLC (“HRE”), initiated a series
of lawsuits, which reinforced his sole stake in The Platters name,
finding his rights superior to all others.
Determination by Mr. Reed
resulted in the right choice by the courts. It's nice he was able to see
it all happen prior to his death. Good for you Herb Reed.
Herb Reed was the only member of the vocal group to appear on all 400 of their recordings and toured with one of the numerous incarnations of the band until 2011.
As the last surviving original member of The Platters, Reed waged a long, but successful, federal court battle over the rights to the name, The Platters. The courts ruled that Reed was the only heir to the group's name.
FTC Disclosure: If you make a purchase via a link on this site, I may receive a small commission on the transaction - at no added cost to you. Thank you!
Congratulations on an outstanding site. I am from old school. I was 13 when Rock & Roll erupted in 1955. I would literally run home from school to watch Bandstand every day. I lived outside Philly and grew up with all the Philadelphia music scene and its performers. Keep up the good work and I thank you for your time and effort in keeping the old vinyl music alive for us and future generations.
Bill was our first newsletter subscriber.
Rest easy my friend.
Danny, I think you did a great job and my family enjoyed it as well. I have had some more time to go through your site and find it to be fantastic, and your personal story is great as well.
are a blessing to all of Us. Thanks for sharing your memories with us. I
look forward to seeing and hearing more from you.
The song "You Were Mine" was written by Paul Giacalone. Read the story here.
I just read your article on Duke of Earl/Vee Jay Records. My father was Randy Wood, President of Vee Jay at the time. I'm doing some research on the company and am learning how influential Vee Jay was in shaping the future of music. Nice to see your web page. Read the Duke of Earl story.
February 15, 2015
A truly beautiful song with words that reflect the long lasting meaning of love.
"But just tell me you love me and you are only mine ...
And our love will go on 'til the end of time." Read more ...
Danny, Great job !!!! I can't express enough how much my mother would have been so happy with your work on her song. As for myself and the rest of my family, we really appreciate your time & effort to let everyone who is interested in her song know the true story behind it. Read more...
Thanx so much, Bob
Switch off the lights and this romantic tune will send you back to the late 50s when this song was so popular. As a testament to its longevity, the song is frequently played on the radio today, 60 years after it was first released in 1959. Read more ...
"I don't usually contact doo wop article authors as I rarely find much value in the articles, but your article struck me as sincere, genuine and respectful."
Producer, Audio Engineer
"In The Still Of The Night" (1956)
Read the story here.
The "Marcels" were named after a popular hairstyle of the day. A great song, a great group and the live video will have YOU dancing in the aisle. Read more ...
Wanna return to that good music era? Come with me and relive yet another great time in history when "One Fine Day" lit up the summer of '63. Read more ...
If you lived and breathed in the fifties those songs of the past reminds us of our connection to innocence and the fabulous harmonies of these four pretty gals.
More than 60 years later, the emotional power of these two songs still resonates with listeners, and as a result, still remains current. Read more ...
If there were ever a song with perfect lyrics that you just wanted to share with others and send back in time it would surely have to be the vinyl record memories of this classic love song, Key Largo. Read this true story.
Watch as the original "Diamonds" perform live for the last time, this great American classic. Read more...
Did the song lyrics predict the girls future?
Eddie, my love ... I'm sinking fast
The very next day ... might be my last
Please, Eddie, don't make me wait too long.
Read their story and their final tragic ending. Learn more ..
This Darling Lorraine page returns to 1959 and the remarkable story about a determined song writer. Includes memorable video clip with original lead singer. Read more here.
Vinyl Record Lovers - This free newsletter is delivered monthly, straight to your INBOX. It covers all new pages since the last issue. Sign up here ...
I value your trust and will use your email address only two send you the Vinyl Record Lovers newsletter.