Johnny Maestro
Vinyl Record Memories

Step by Step, Sixteen Candles &
The Worst That Could Happen.

Johnny Maestro vinyl record memories. The Doo wop group Brooklyn Bridge and the song Sixteen Candles.

The Johnny Maestro vinyl record memories all started in the late 1950s when he was the lead singer for The Crests, fronting hits like "Sixteen Candles," "Trouble in Paradise," "The Angels Listened In," and "Step by Step."

The Crests were a band of street kids from the Lower East Side, and quite a rare mix back in the 50s. There were three blacks, (one was a girl) one Puerto Rican, and Johnny Maestro, the lone Italian. They performed at parties and dances and rode the subway for the drop of a few coins.

One day a rider handed them a business card that led to a record contract.

One of the most fondly remembered of doo wop hits, "Sixteen Candles" by the Crests possessed the simplistic, amateur feel of many doo wop singles, but was actually produced by a veteran label (Coed) and written by a veteran composer (Luther Dixon, who had hits with the Shirelles and the Platters).

On the Coed label, they recorded “Beside You” and  the B side was Sixteen Candles. "Who knew," Johnny said in a 1994 interview. The pure-toned tenor voice of Johnny Maestro was most of the reason this song became a hit. The song was released in November of 1958 and became a #2 hit on the National Charts in 1959.

When you listen to the Crests you are sampling some of the very best that doo-wop has to offer, and you also get a glimpse of where the music was headed at the time. Their records had everything a rock"n"roll record should have to appeal to teenagers, plus enough emotion to carry older audiences as well.

Johnny Maestro Vinyl Record Memories.
Brooklyn Bridge - How is all started.

Brooklyn Bridge vinyl record memories, The Johnny Maestro Story.

The original Brooklyn Bridge had 11 members, singing and playing.

The Bridge, as the group is often called, was a merger in 1968 of two bands, the Del-Satins and the Rhythm Method. It was originally billed as Johnny Maestro, the Del-Satins and the Rhythm Method. A bit too bulky.

So we decided we’d pick a new one, Johnny told a reporter in 1994. We were sitting around the office, and someone said: "This is going to be difficult. We have 11 people. That’s hard to sell. It’s easier to sell the Brooklyn Bridge." We said, "That’s the name."

With their strong vocal and horn arrangements, the Bridge recorded a series of hits, including “Welcome Me Love,” “You’ll Never Walk Alone” and “Your Husband, My Wife.” But lightning struck for the band with songwriter Jimmy Webb’s “Worst That Could Happen.”

In December 1968, the "Brooklyn Bridge" performed the song on The Ed Sullivan Show. In the song, a man sings about the impending marriage of a woman he still loves, and reluctantly wishes her well. Johnny sings...

"If he loves you more than me, maybe it’s the best thing, maybe it’s the best thing for you, but it’s the worst that could happen to me.”

Band member, Les Cauchi said, "That Sullivan show appearance launched our career.”

"Cousin Brucie" on Johnny Maestro.


During an interview with veteran radio host, author and music historian Bruce "Cousin Brucie" Morrow, who worked with Maestro many times said, "Of all the talent, Johnny was the smoothest."

"He probably sounded more like his recordings live than any other performer. He always held true to the music and treated it with great respect."

Listen to the great Johnny Maestro & Brooklyn Bridge singing Step by Step, Sixteen candles, and The worst that could happen, introduced by "Cousin Brucie" Morrow on "Shake Rattle and Roll" in 1988.

Enjoy the three great performances in the video below and you can hear why "Cousin Brucie" said Johnny sounded more like his recordings live than any other performer. 

I was fourteen years old in 1958 when I first heard The Crests singing "Sixteen Candles." Listening to Johnny Maestro and The Brooklyn Bridge swept me back to a time many of us refer to as the good old days....Saturday nights, first dates, soda shops, cruising endlessly going nowhere, and who can forget sneaking into the drive-in movie theater in the trunk of a car.

As time marches on and old memories fade for some, the one thing time made better was the silky voice of Johnny Maestro, allowing us a brief return to those vinyl record memories and the classic Sixteen Candles we all heard for the first time...back in the good old days. 

John Peter Mastrangelo was born on the Lower East Side of Manhattan on May 7, 1939. He died at age 70 on March 24, 2010 at his home in Cape Coral, Fla.

Thanks for the memories, Johnny.

Return to Doo-wop main page.

Visit the classic golden oldies main page.

Return to Home page.

The Skyliners
"Since I Don't Have You"

Switch off the lights and this romantic tune will send you back to the late 50s when this song was so popular. As a testament to its longevity, the song is frequently played on the radio today, 60 years after it was first released in 1959. Read more ...

Watch The Skyliners live in concert.

Enjoy this page? Share it with your friends!

Would you prefer to share this page with others by linking to it?

  1. Click on the HTML link code below.
  2. Copy and paste it, adding a note of your own, into your blog, a Web page, forums, a blog comment, your Facebook account, or anywhere that someone would find this page valuable.
Top of Page

Vinyl Record Memories Newsletter

Go to Vinyl Record Memories Newsletter Sign up page.

A Little Bit of Nostalgia in your inbox each month.

SignUp Today

A walk down memory lane. Relive the music, the times, the era.  Meet the pioneers who started it all with great photos, posters, album covers, newspaper articles, magazine covers, lyrics, and more.

Vinyl Record Memories from the 50s, 60s & 70s.  Read my stories, listen to all the great oldies.  Read more...

Go to the Oldies Music pages and relive old memories.

Many consider "In The Still of The Night" to be the anthem of Doo Wop oldies and it would be hard to argue that point giving the year the song was originally released, 1956. Read more.

Go to Five Satins page | Listen to original 45rpm record.

This Darling Lorraine page returns to 1959 and the remarkable story about a determined song writer. Includes memorable video clip with original lead singer. Read more here.

Listen to the original 45rpm recording of "The Locomotion" and watch the best dance version ever!  Read more.

"Looking For An Echo" is street corner music with soul. A time when the ability to sing was mandatory. Read more...

"We practiced in a subway,
In a lobby or a hall
Crowded in a doorway

Singing "Doo-wops" to the wall"

Go to the Kenny Vance page to enjoy this wonderful song.

Don't Break The Heart
That Loves You.

This haunting ballad is about a plea from a heartbroken teenager trying to understand why her boyfriend is going out of his way to treat her unkindly. Read more...

"Why Do I Love You So"

This 1960 teen love song was a short song with a long-lasting heartbroken message. One of the more romantic teen ballads written at the time. Read More ...

Johnny's re-issue of this classic in 1965 proves that some do turn out better.

The End - Earl Grant

A truly beautiful song with words that reflect the long lasting meaning of love.

"But just tell me you love me and you are only mine ...
And our love will go on 'til the end of time."  Read more ...

Go to Earl Grant page and read the story of this talented man and beautiful song.